DVD Reviews

DVD For Sale From Amazon.Com
DVD Release Dates
Movie Posters At Allposters.com
DVD Special Sales
Video Release Dates

[ Jump to: Image Review | Audio Review |Extras Review | Menu Review | Final Grades | Back To A Guide To Current DVD | ]

Currentfilm.com Review:

"I Am Legend" remained in development for many years, with Arnold Schwarzenegger once in place to star with Ridley Scott and then at one point even Michael Bay was thought to be the possible director of the movie. There's also been other stars and directors considered throughout the years, but the pairing eventually wound up being "Constantine" director Francis Lawrence and actor Will Smith. While the fact that Akiva Goldsman's name credited as screenwriter is cause for dismay, the film has turned out better than I'd expected.

The film stars Smith as Dr. Robert Neville, a former military scientist who now finds himself the only resident left in New York City. A few years earlier, what was supposed to be a cure for cancer turned on the world, mutating into a virus that turned people into what appear to be bloodthirsty, vampire-like creatures.

As far as Neville knows, he is the last person on Earth, an immune survivor who roams the deserted streets with his dog by day and shutters himself in at night in order to work on finding a cure. One of the film's most remarkable achievements is how it has convincingly created a desolate Manhattan, with overgrown vegetation, animals running wild (an early scene has Neville hunting deer, only to have a lion swiftly snatch the prey for itself) and signs of the chaos that occured still plainly visible on every street.

The film's other best element is Smith, who gives what very well may be his finest performance here as a man losing his sanity as he tries to save the downfall of civilization. Scenes where he talks to store dummies he's set up to try and have some sort of imaginary company could have been utterly ridiculous, but thanks to Smith's exceptional performance, they grow increasingly moving. The film is - up until the last stretch - essentially a one-man show and not only does Smith capably handle that, he impresses greatly.

The film does have a few flaws, however. While the film's transformation of Manhattan is haunting, disturbing and just plain remarkable (when hearing that they were going to film this picture in New York City, I didn't believe it could be done), the creatures themselves look like generic CGI monsters. They also look a little too CGI. The CGI used to create the animals that occasionally zip through the quiet streets fares somewhat better. Overall, the film's CGI is a little all-over-the-place, with some CGI use that is astonishing and other instances that are just iffy. The film works as a PG-13, but one wonders what the film would be like as an R.

The film's last act, when Robert finds out that he is not the last survivor, sees it starting to lose its footing, but even with some plot holes and a few questionable moments (including one involving "Shrek"), the movie still manages to up the tension as it heads into an intense close. At 100 minutes, the movie remains tight and tense, although the movie does manage to offer a balance between action and quieter, dramatic moments. Overall, while not without flaws, I liked this film quite a bit and director Francis Lawrence manages to once again positions himself as a reasonably promising big-budget director.


VIDEO: The Blu-Ray edition of the film is presented in 2.35:1 (1080P/VC-1) by Warner Brothers Home Entertainment. Presentation quality is certainly impressive, as many scenes offer an exceptional level of fine detail - even into the backgrounds. Pores on Smith's face and the hair on his dog are presented with crystal clarity. Scenes in the daytime on the streets of NYC look crisper and more detailed, with greater depth to the image. The Blu-Ray presentation makes some minor background details - a Time Magazine article with the Smith character's face stuck to the refrigerator in the character's home - stand out more clearly, whereas I would probably have not noticed it on DVD.

The presentation does not show any instances of print flaws or edge enhancement, but some minor, hardly noticable noise is seen in a few instances. The film's mostly subdued (intentionally, obviously) color palette appeared accurately presented, not looking smeary or otherwise problematic.

SOUND: The film is presented on Blu-Ray in Dolby TrueHD, as well as Dolby Digital 5.1 (English, French and Spanish options). While it wasn't quite as fierce or aggressive as one might expect, it really did provide a wonderfully enveloping experience, such as one particular scene where Neville has to hunt through an abandoned building after his dog ran in. Surrounds are put to great use during the film, both in the most intense sequences and quieter moments for effects and ambience. Audio quality was excellent, with impressive clarity and moments of deep, strong bass.

EXTRAS: "Creating I Am Legend" is an extensive documentary that is made up of many smaller segments (thankfully there's a "play all", because trying to watch all these short segments without it would have gotten a little tedious to have to go back to the menu each time.) The documentaries can be a little fluffy and none go into terrific depth, but there are good tidbits and behind-the-scenes clips scattered throughout the programs and it is interesting watching the production try to film in the midst of New York City. The other, shorter documentary is "Cautionary Tale: The Science of I Am Legend", which takes a look at the reality of viruses. The four animated comics that were included on the regular DVD edition are also brought over for the Blu-Ray release.

The "alternate ending" version of the film (the ending being the difference from the theatrical cut) that was available on the second DVD of the Special Edition DVD set is available here, as viewers can choose between both versions of the film on the Blu-Ray. I won't spoil it, so lets just say that the alternate version (which runs an extra 4 minutes) is alternate for a reason: it really doesn't work very well.

Final Thoughts: Overall, while not without flaws, I liked this film quite a bit and director Francis Lawrence manages to once again positions himself as a reasonably promising big-budget director. The Blu-Ray edition of the film not only offers a fantastic audio/video presentation of the film that improves upon the very good standard DVD presentation, but the extras are more easily accessible. Recommended.

Film Grade
The Film B
DVD Grades
Video 98/A
Audio: 92/A
Extras: 70/C-

DVD Information

I Am Legend (Blu-Ray)
Warner Brothers Home Entertainment
100/104 minutes
Subtitles: English
Rated PG-13
Available At Amazon.com: I Am Legend (single disc widescreen) DVD,I Am Legend (Blu-Ray),I Am Legend: 2-DVD Edition DVD,I Am Legend: HD-DVD